Filmina··8 min read

Elaborative interrogation: studying by asking why

Listen to article 8:44

Elaborative interrogation is a very simple study technique: for every idea in your material, you ask yourself "why is this true?" and answer from what you already know, before moving on. It isn't reading the textbook's explanation: it's building it yourself. The slide says that when the central bank raises interest rates, consumer spending tends to fall; you ask why, and you answer that borrowing gets more expensive and saving pays more, so people put purchases off.

It works because it forces you to connect the new fact to something already in your head, and connected facts are easier to remember than loose ones. A fact with its why fades much slower than a fact alone. It takes a bit longer than reading straight through, but every idea actually goes through your head instead of just past your eyes.

Here's where it comes from, what the research says (it's good, with clear limits), how I use it with a macroeconomics lecture and when another technique is the better pick.

Where it comes from

The idea comes from a series of experiments by Michael Pressley and his colleagues in the late 1980s. In one of the first, people read arbitrary sentences like "the fat man read the sign". Some just read them; some got the sentence with the explanation already written in ("read the sign warning about thin ice"); and some were asked why that particular man would do that, and had to come up with the answer themselves.

The people who answered on their own remembered much more than the ones who just read, and more than the ones handed the explanation. That's the core of the technique: it isn't enough for the explanation to exist in your notes. You have to produce it.

Later studies used material closer to college reading: paragraphs of facts about universities, provinces or animals. In an experiment by Woloshyn, Pressley and Schneider, asking why each fact made sense helped people remember more, and what they already knew about the topic mattered even more. The technique helped everyone, but it paid off far more for people who had something to hang the facts on.

What the research says, without overselling it

A large review of study techniques by Dunlosky and colleagues rated it moderate utility: it works, it's easy to learn and it needs almost no prep, but most of the studies used lists of facts and short sentences, and there's less evidence for long, complex texts or for exams many weeks later.

What that means for your courses:

It isn't enough for the why to be in your notes: you have to build it yourself.

How to do it, step by step

This is how I do it with any lecture deck:

  1. Take one claim at a time. A bullet on a slide, a sentence in the textbook. Not the whole topic.
  2. Ask why it's true. Literally: "why does this happen?" or "why would this make sense?"
  3. Answer without looking, in one or two sentences, from what you know about the course or about life. Writing it down or saying it out loud both work.
  4. Check it against the material. If your answer matches, move on. If it doesn't, fix it and note what was missing.
  5. Flag what you couldn't answer. Those are the ideas you don't understand yet, even if you can repeat them.

That last step is the one that helps me most. If you can't give it a why, you don't understand it yet, even if you know it by heart. And that list of ideas without a why is exactly what to bring to office hours.

An example from a macroeconomics lecture

A typical monetary policy slide has three bullets like these:

Read straight through, all three seem obvious and are gone in two days. With the technique:

On the second bullet, you probably won't have an answer the first time. That's the signal: you go back to the textbook or the lecture, you figure it out, and next time you try again without looking. The same works in a management course ("why does a wider span of control mean fewer layers of management?") or in consumer behavior ("why can a well-known brand charge more?").

The questions that pay off most

"Why?" is the base, but a few variations help depending on the course:

If your answers start getting longer and chaining together, you're close to the Feynman technique: explaining the whole topic in plain words, as if to someone who knows nothing. Elaborative interrogation is the small version, bullet by bullet; Feynman is the big one, topic by topic.

Common mistakes

With your lecture slides

Doing this with a forty-slide deck takes time, and the hardest part is checking your answers when your notes don't include the why. That's where I use Filmina, a web app that explains your lecture slides out loud: first I ask myself why an idea is true and answer on my own, then I listen to the explanation of that slide or ask Mina, the chat that answers from your own material, to see whether my answer held up. The explanation comes after the attempt, not before, or the technique loses what makes it work. It needs a connection and the free plan has a monthly cap on minutes; to do it without any app, the textbook and a page with two columns are enough.

Frequently asked questions

What is elaborative interrogation?

It's a study technique where, for each idea in your material, you ask yourself why it's true and answer from what you already know. It helps memory because it ties the new fact to knowledge you already have.

Does elaborative interrogation work?

Yes, with limits. A large review of study techniques rated it moderate utility: it works well with facts and claims, especially when you already know something about the topic, and there's less evidence for long, complex material.

What's the difference between elaborative interrogation and the Feynman technique?

Elaborative interrogation goes idea by idea: you ask why each claim is true. The Feynman technique takes a whole topic and has you explain it in plain words, as if to someone who knows nothing, to find the gaps.

How do you use elaborative interrogation when studying?

Take one claim at a time, ask why it's true, answer without looking in one or two sentences, then check against the material. Flag the ones you couldn't answer: those are the ones you don't understand yet.

Keep reading

·6 min

How to memorize dates and names without mixing them up

How to memorize dates and names for an exam: a timeline with stories, self-testing, the memory palace and spaced review, with examples from history.

·8 min

How to make a concept map for studying (that actually helps)

How to make a concept map for studying: the focus question, the concept list, linking words that say something, and how to redraw it from memory.

·7 min

The interleaving study technique: why mixing topics prepares you better for exams

Interleaving mixes topics and problem types instead of studying them in blocks. What it is, when it works, when it doesn't and how to set it up.

Let's start
studying

Upload your next lecture and Mina does the rest: explains it, sums it up, quizzes you.